Re: Worst Final Four.... ever      1-May-08 10:12 am    
I have to contemplate the idea that the voting public have only a very small part in who stays and who goes on AI. David C. is the best all around performer/singer and will more than likely win. David A. is a very talented singer but not a performer and will by all account be the runner up. Syesha will end up on Broadway with some of her contemporaries. But be honest, I can not see any person on earth buying a CD or attending a concert by Jason Castro. Who would want to listen to 26 songs that sound exactly the same? I know he should have been gone long ago, and in your hearts you know the same. But with Paula's screw up, the producers could not let him go without someone crying foul. If Jason goes after Brook, or before is a matter of preference, but He absolutely has to go. For all you little girls that think Jason is the cats ass, next time he sings, don't watch, just listen and then tell us honestly you still believe he's the best. Do the same for each one, and you'll start to understand what each one brings to the table. A performer has already won on AI, "Taylor Hicks," it's a shame no one closed their eyes and listened to him that year. When someone produces a CD, it doesn't matter if he is the greatest performer on earth, or a stick person because you don't see him/her you listen to them. Personality comes out in their music, Brook was a perfect example. Behind a piano, you were forced to listen to her, not watch. She excelled, proving that this is supposed to be a singing contest, not a personality driven performance contest. If I am wrong, and the popular vote did save Jason, the all I can say is America you got it very very wrong.
Rating :
 (1 Rating)
Rate it:
awful/not related to \pooraveragegoodexcellent

Terry A

60/Male
Illinois


View Messages

Ignore User

Report Abuse

View: Simple | Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Msg List
Page 1 of about 1   First | < Prev | Next > | Last

Messages in Topic

View messages rated: What's this?
  Subject Author Rating Time of Post (ET)  
 
Jason Castro? Syesha? David Archuleta? Are you kidding me? I wish I would have known these 3 woul...
Kevin S 1-May-08 08:35 am  
 
I agree totally but you have to help me out here. How is it that we can see this about David Ar...
SnowHarp Rate it 1-May-08 08:45 am  
 
Oh yeah the fix has been in for Archuleta since the beginning. Think about it, they never ...
Kevin S Rate it 1-May-08 08:51 am  
 
I don't think any of America understands this? He has no personality at all. Maybe they ar...
LarryandJ Rate it 1-May-08 10:26 am  
 
the demolition job is now on. insecurd fans of other contenders are trying to put down the...
popsmates Rate it 4-May-08 08:38 pm  
 
How do you think he is the frontrunner? The poor kid can sing well, ok, but he has NO...
LarryandJ Rate it 4-May-08 08:41 pm  
 
I still love David A.!!!!! He's shy so what? He can sing. He doesn't know how to be with people...
Aleksei 1-May-08 08:53 am  
 
No, I don't like David Archuleta because he is not good. He is an above average singing an...
Kevin S (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 09:02 am  
 
Well Kevin..... What if example, you were also given the chance to go back to your pa...
Aleksei (1 Rating) 1-May-08 09:11 am  
 
Everybody keeps saying "He's young", oh BS....he's been performing almost as lon...
LarryandJ (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 10:34 am  
 
If Archie Wuss~a~letta won Star Search 4 years or so ago....it should have ...
lok_n2_my_iz (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 10:40 am  
 
Nope. If Archuleta was a wonder kid I would be supporting him. It's a tough business and...
SnowHarp (1 Rating) 1-May-08 09:03 am  
 
"Do you think we are going to see him rocking audiences with his music five years fro...
beachboyfan1 (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 09:08 am  
 
It's not about the money that inspires you from singing. It's not the gold. Even...
Aleksei 1-May-08 09:19 am  
 
As much as he's been shoved in the spotlight, since he was like 2?, how can he not be used...
LarryandJ (1 Rating) 1-May-08 10:30 am  
 
Having a son with Autism,I take exception to your Down Syndrom remark.Lots of special needs kid...
beachboyfan1 1-May-08 09:04 am  
 
As a dedicated fan/viewer of the show, AI is becoming a joke, time to rename the show American ...
Sixburgh Rate it 1-May-08 09:35 am  
 
Re: Worst Final Four.... ever
Terry A (1 Rating) 1-May-08 10:12 am  
 
I agree with the david cook and archueta parts.
go danny go Rate it 1-May-08 10:28 am  
 
i dont know if this is the worst final four, but its up there. When fantasia won, i think that...
coelus (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 10:56 am  
 
You know the facts Coel. If the ratings keep going down, like they're saying this year, th...
LarryandJ (1 Rating) 1-May-08 11:00 am  
 
in me head! look whos irish now! move over carly!
go danny go (1 Rating) 1-May-08 11:02 am  
 
doesnt make sense does it? since there's no way to prove the number of votes the s...
coelus (1 Rating) 1-May-08 11:05 am  
 
AI is a money machine - plain and simple. More votes, more money. I have to be...
SnowHarp (1 Rating) 1-May-08 11:17 am  
 
i agree david c is okay and syesha is pretty good also, but that david a. c...
gwen w (2 Ratings) 1-May-08 11:21 am  
 
please gwen..i think i would stone my t.v. if Archie tried to rap!
lok_n2_my_iz Rate it 1-May-08 11:24 am  
 
Each season is different, of course. We have been spoiled by amazing singers through the y...
WEEBLE313 Rate it 1-May-08 07:00 pm  
 
Other than the Davids yep not the best batch of singers the show has seen....not as bad tho and...
Janie Rate it 2-May-08 12:23 pm  
 
Ruben winning was a perfect example of the show being a sham.
Chief Rate it 2-May-08 12:27 pm  
 
yes it was! theres no way in the world Ruben beat out Clay! That was the first time ...
coelus Rate it 2-May-08 12:29 pm  
 
And you get the credit for telling it like it is a while back while everyone cal...
Chief Rate it 2-May-08 12:31 pm  
 
lol. im SAD that im being proven right! i wish that the things i said we...
coelus Rate it 2-May-08 12:34 pm  
 
but....we like lunatic rants. Least I do. Keeps things interesting an...
lhunter Rate it 2-May-08 04:39 pm  
 
For me, the appeal is the way a person sounds more than what he looks like. You can appreciate...
Susan
Online Now
(1 Rating) 2-May-08 09:22 pm  
 
Oh yeah, the Eagles.....great group!
Chief Rate it 2-May-08 09:26 pm  
 
Honestly I think this the best out of all of them. I am betting for Jason Castro. Though his ...
yogibear968 Rate it 4-May-08 07:59 pm  
View: Simple | Summary | Expanded
As: Threaded | Msg List
Page 1 of about 1   First | < Prev | Next > | Last
< Newer Topic | Older Topic >