|
Do you think the changes to "American Idol" will hurt or help the show?
Rating :
  (353 Ratings) |
Female |
Messages in Topic
| Subject | Author | Rating | Time of Post (ET) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Y! TV Post: 'Idol' Show Changes
|
tv gal |
 
|
12-Jan-09 06:31 pm | ||
|
It will help the show. I like the judges deciding the final three.
|
LUCY J |
|
13-Jan-09 01:37 am | ||
|
I agree I do watch American Idol and for the past maybe 2 years I noticed I tune less and ...
|
BW |
|
13-Jan-09 01:22 pm | ||
|
I definitely agree with your comment about the old guests. Geez, I'm going to be 49 i...
|
PatriciaT | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 11:45 pm | ||
|
I think all the changes will boost the ratings up and are necessary changes to the show to...
|
Robert |
|
13-Jan-09 01:24 pm | ||
|
The changes aren't going to change anything. The show has run it's course, and it's t...
|
raiders757 |
|
13-Jan-09 01:45 pm | ||
|
I agree!
|
MICHAEL S |
|
13-Jan-09 02:09 pm | ||
|
it has not run it's course. this isn't an entirely scripted show that could run ...
|
ashley |
|
13-Jan-09 03:47 pm | ||
|
This show is so scripted it screams. The only reason people like to watch ...
|
The Man from L... | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 04:12 pm | ||
|
I couldn't disagree more! I certainly don't watch it to see other peop...
|
IdolFan | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 04:33 pm | ||
|
i beg to differ, while some of the show is scripted[it has to be,they ...
|
ashley |
|
13-Jan-09 04:52 pm | ||
|
I'd have to agree. I have been ADDICTED to this show since seas...
|
quinn | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 06:19 pm | ||
|
I agree with most of what you are saying. For me logging on week afte...
|
Cassandre S
Online Now
|
Rate it | 13-Jan-09 10:08 pm | ||
|
Maybe. Maybe not. Everything runs it course just like sitcoms. It will happ...
|
uknowme | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 06:23 pm | ||
|
Even though you say, "move on", you will have your eyes glued to, if not the who...
|
Dennis | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 04:33 pm | ||
|
I agree whole heartedly. It's time has run out. I vowed to never watch again aft...
|
uknowme | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 06:19 pm | ||
|
I totally agree. Out with the old and boring and in with something new. Just k...
|
mei ling365 | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 11:19 pm | ||
|
This is to Matt Whitfield. I did not like thecomment about the liver spots. Who do you t...
|
classy6granny |
|
13-Jan-09 01:35 pm | ||
|
I lost interest and stopped watching a few seasons ago. Dragging out who was staying ...
|
alreadyjumped |
|
13-Jan-09 01:46 pm | ||
|
not all good things come to an end prematurely, and neither will american idol. ...
|
ashley | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 03:51 pm | ||
|
Yeah granny! Matt Whitfield should keep this article and read it again when he's burn...
|
Hot60 |
|
13-Jan-09 03:05 pm | ||
|
Like I said, when he has liver spots, he'll also be getting several enemas a day...
|
Chanel227 |
|
13-Jan-09 04:52 pm | ||
|
Could not agree more...who is this Matt creep anyway?
|
Suzie | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 06:01 pm | ||
|
so tell me who invented rock n roll....
|
supa_man222000 | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 06:40 pm | ||
|
Good Lord Granny...lighten up...he just wanted more younger singers coming to mentor ...
|
Carol M | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 03:53 pm | ||
|
I don't think Granny should have to lighten up! It seems to so in vogue to trash...
|
Chanel227 |
|
13-Jan-09 04:50 pm | ||
|
I support granny 100%, Neil Diamonds voice may be all but gone, but he can still out ...
|
The Man from L... |
|
13-Jan-09 04:08 pm | ||
|
That may be true, but the point is American Idol appealing to a younger audience...
|
Chrissy J | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 05:12 pm | ||
|
Who are you kidding? You think that someone who has been using their vocal...
|
life4real | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 06:17 pm | ||
|
Why on EARTH does everyone think FANTASIA can sing??!! She was AWFUL...anyone can sin...
|
Jess
Online Now
|
|
13-Jan-09 04:46 pm | ||
|
I agree with you 1000%. She is the WORST singer/winner ever crowned on Idol... w...
|
Serge M | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 04:56 pm | ||
|
Since her May 2004 win on Idol, Fantasia released her single "I Believe" which s...
|
Mrs. R. |
|
13-Jan-09 05:10 pm | ||
|
Thank you!!!!!!!!!!!!! People should do their research before they comment...
|
Chrissy J | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 05:34 pm | ||
|
She has a political correct voice, I would not buy her DVD because to me he...
|
mercyyless | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 10:45 pm | ||
|
She could win TEN grammies, write FIVE books, be in FOUR plays....who cares...
|
Jess
Online Now
|
Rate it | 14-Jan-09 10:13 pm | ||
|
Maybe more homework should be done on the "art" of singing and the different typ...
|
Chrissy J |
|
13-Jan-09 05:29 pm | ||
|
Ha yeah, theres tons of types of music but she cant even sing her style rig...
|
Jared | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 07:33 pm | ||
|
THANK YOU!!!
Wow she was the worst singer since janice joplin
everything that ...
|
dj dstroy |
|
13-Jan-09 05:49 pm | ||
|
EXACTLY. She was awful. I used to say she sounded like donald duck whenever she ...
|
Jared | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 07:27 pm | ||
|
I coudn't agree with you more. I always changed the channel when Fantasia ...
|
R and P | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 10:59 pm | ||
|
He'll be getting lots of enemas because he's so full of crap, and loving every minute...
|
Chanel227 | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 04:48 pm | ||
|
To Classy6granny,
I back you 100%. Most younger people nowadays don't know their b...
|
Sherri |
|
13-Jan-09 05:13 pm | ||
|
Matt Whitfield, the writer of this article, is incredibly annoying. So much so, that ...
|
C G | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 05:16 pm | ||
|
I agree. That comment was a bit harsh. The older singers are the ones with experience...
|
Candy | (2 Ratings) | 13-Jan-09 05:41 pm | ||
|
Yeah, if the liver spots are of concerned to television programing now, I have an off...
|
Jett | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 06:12 pm | ||
|
Well said (except for the typos)!
|
ConnieB | Rate it | 13-Jan-09 09:43 pm | ||
|
Mick Jagger and some of the "Stones" are in their mid-60's and still going strong. S...
|
Chief | (1 Rating) | 13-Jan-09 10:19 pm | ||
|
Keep the "untalented" on the auditions it's important for entertainment and if it is taken...
|
queenie |
|
13-Jan-09 01:57 pm | ||
|
You are exactly right, queenie....
|
princess |
|
13-Jan-09 02:07 pm | ||
|
I agree 100%!! That's why most of us tune in to the auditions; we want to see the tra...
|
KP
Online Now
|
|
13-Jan-09 02:11 pm |